Puffin Travel choice – We decide where to go. Do it like locals

Reviewed · PUFFIN WATCHING TOURS

Puffin Travel choice – We decide where to go. Do it like locals

5.0 · 15 reviews From $865 Operated by Puffin Travel · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

A full day in Iceland, without the crowds. This private Reykjavik experience shines because it’s truly custom and guided by locals Gulla and Villi, with Wi-Fi on board to keep you connected while you’re chasing big views. I also like how they treat your bucket list like a real plan, not a suggestion, and you’ll likely get better timing than a one-size-fits-all bus day. One drawback to keep in mind: there are no meals included, and you may have limited restroom options during long stretches, since there’s no restroom on the vehicle.

If you want to do Iceland like a local—meaning flexible stops, smart pacing, and a day that matches your group’s vibe—this is the kind of tour that works. The guides talk through your interests fast (art, knitting, saga culture, nature, thermal baths, even kid-friendly activities), then build a day around that, usually in the 7–12 hour range depending on what you choose. The trade-off is that your itinerary depends on your interests and the day’s conditions, so it won’t be identical for everyone.

From the reviews, the most praised themes are personal hosting (it can feel like a family friend day), lots of off-the-beaten-path driving choices, and a clean, comfortable private vehicle. Some guests also asked for a touch more explanation at certain points, which is a fair reminder: if you want deeper storytelling at every stop, tell Gulla or Villi upfront.

Key Points I’d Focus on Before You Book

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - Key Points I’d Focus on Before You Book

  • Guides who customize fast around your interests (art, knitting, sagas, thermal baths, kids)
  • Private, crowd-light routing after doing the Golden Circle the usual way elsewhere
  • Wi-Fi in the vehicle for updates, maps, and staying in touch
  • Local hosts Gulla and Villi who act like guides, not just drivers
  • Good value when splitting the day among your group since you’re paying for planning and flexibility

More time with the puffins out on the bay

A Reykjavik Day Trip That Feels Like Yours, Not a Script

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - A Reykjavik Day Trip That Feels Like Yours, Not a Script
The best part of this tour is the tone. You’re not locked into a rigid schedule where you spend 20 minutes walking and 3 hours waiting. You’re in a private vehicle with a guide who asks what you actually care about, then spends the day building your route around it.

Two things I especially like: first, the way your interests drive the plan. Want nature? They steer you toward uniquely Icelandic areas. Want culture and sagas? They can shape the day around stories and local context. Want something hands-on like knitting or a visit connected to art? That’s part of the conversation too. Second, the practical comfort: Wi-Fi on board means you can coordinate with your group, check quick details, and keep your phone useful instead of stuck in airplane-mode misery.

Here’s the one consideration: this is a full-day experience with a lot of driving potential, and meals are not included. If you’re the kind of traveler who needs a built-in lunch plan, you’ll want to budget time to stop for food your own way.

Meet Gulla and Villi: Personalized Planning That Starts Before You Go

This tour is hosted by Gulla and Villi, and they’re the heart of the experience. Gulla’s approach is flexible and interest-led—she’ll literally talk through your bucket list and help translate it into a route. Villi is described as friendly, informative, and attentive to group needs, with many options you can choose from as the day progresses.

From guest feedback, one of the most memorable feelings is how personal the day becomes. People talk about it feeling like being hosted by an old family friend, which usually doesn’t happen on standard group tours. Another common theme: the driving wasn’t just efficient, it was thoughtful—stops were chosen to match the mood of the day, not just the most famous checkboxes.

That said, there’s a subtle lesson here. One review note suggested the explanations could be stronger at some points. If you want lots of narration—history, geology, culture—say so early. A private guide will usually match the level you ask for, but you have to ask.

How the Custom Route Works Across the Golden Circle, South Coast, and More

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - How the Custom Route Works Across the Golden Circle, South Coast, and More
At a high level, you can think of this as a choose-your-own Iceland day with a local editor. Your guide can point you toward classic areas like the Golden Circle, the south coast, or the Reykjanes Peninsula. And if your timing and interests align, the plan can also reach places like the Landmannalaugar lava fields—an option that signals you’re not just doing the postcard version of Iceland.

Your day typically starts around 9:30 am, and the total time is flexible (roughly 8 to 9 hours as listed, with guidance that it can run 7–12 hours depending on what you want to pack in). That flexibility matters because Iceland is a place where “how much you do” is strongly influenced by weather and light. A private setup lets you adjust without losing the whole schedule.

The route can also be interest-coded, not just location-coded. For example:

  • If you’re into nature, expect focus on dramatic, uniquely Icelandic areas.
  • If you want thermal baths, you can ask about natural options.
  • If your group includes children, the guide can plan kid-friendly activities.
  • If you’re into art, knitting, or saga culture, those themes can shape what you do and where you stop.

This is where the value shows up for the right traveler: you’re paying for real decision-making power, not just transportation.

What Each Possible Region Gives You (and Where Time Can Slip)

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - What Each Possible Region Gives You (and Where Time Can Slip)
Because this tour is customized, I can’t promise a single exact route for every booking. But you can map out what each option tends to deliver, and what to watch for. Here’s how the major Iceland options mentioned for this day tend to work in practice.

Golden Circle: Classic Iceland, but with better pacing

The Golden Circle is the famous circuit, so expect you’ll recognize the type of stops—big scenery, iconic viewpoints, that sort of thing. The advantage of doing it with Gulla or Villi is that you’re not stuck as one of a thousand people in the same order. You can fit it into your day based on what you’ve already seen and what your group likes.

The drawback is simple: it can still feel like a highlight marathon if you rush. With a private guide, you avoid some of the worst crowd time, but you’ll still want to agree early on how many stops you truly want.

South Coast: Dramatic drives and a real sense of scale

The south coast option is about the kind of Iceland where the drive itself feels like part of the attraction. If your group likes seeing variety in a single day—weather, geology, changing views—this is often a strong choice.

Time can slip here because roads and conditions can influence your actual pacing. The good news: when your guide is planning your day around your interests, you can prioritize the stops that matter most to you rather than seeing everything halfway.

Reykjanes Peninsula: Geothermal vibes with a different flavor

Reykjanes Peninsula is a geothermal and volcanic region, which tends to attract travelers who like Iceland’s science side as much as its views. If you’re curious about the geothermal feel—steam, earth energy, and that volcanic setting—this option can create a day that feels distinct from the Golden Circle.

Practical consideration: it’s easy to burn time hunting for the perfect photo angle. In a private day, that can be great, but it’s smart to set expectations so you still keep space for the rest of your plan.

Landmannalaugar lava fields: For travelers who want intensity

Landmannalaugar is mentioned as a possible destination, and that’s your clue you’re not just doing an easy day. This is the kind of place that rewards travelers who want raw scenery and a stronger sense of “I’m really in Iceland.”

The drawback is logistical realism. You’ll want a guide who can manage the timing and weather reality of the day, because Iceland doesn’t care about our best intentions.

Thermal baths: Natural soak time, if you build it in

If you want geothermal relaxation, the guides can steer you toward natural thermal bath options. This can be a great anchor for the day because it gives you a break from driving and keeps the experience memorable even if visibility changes.

The thing to remember: meals aren’t included, so if your bath stop becomes your lunch window, you’ll want to plan accordingly. Wear layers you can handle in and out of water and keep an eye on how long you can comfortably spend there.

Interest-based mini-adventures: art, knitting, sagas, kids

One of the coolest parts of this tour is how it can go beyond locations. If you like art, you can visit an artist. If you’re into knitting, you can do a knitting adventure. If you want sagas and culture, Gulla can share stories and context. And if there are children in your group, the guide can add activities built for them.

This is where the tour earns its nickname of doing it like locals. You’re not just consuming scenery; you’re shaping the day around what you’d enjoy back home too.

Comfort and Practicalities: The Car, the Clock, and the Little Frictions

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - Comfort and Practicalities: The Car, the Clock, and the Little Frictions
Let’s talk the practical stuff that can make or break a long day.

You’ll ride in an air-conditioned vehicle with private transportation, and there’s Wi-Fi on board. The Wi-Fi isn’t just a nice extra. In Iceland, it’s handy for group coordination, checking directions, and keeping your day from turning into a guessing game when the light shifts fast.

On the logistics side:

  • Pickup is offered.
  • You start around 9:30 am.
  • You should expect an outing in the 8 to 9 hour range, with flexibility up to about 12 hours depending on what you choose.

Now the friction points:

  • Meals are not included. You’ll want to plan how you and your group handle lunch or snacks.
  • There’s no restroom on board, so you’ll rely on stops. Build that into your mindset and don’t assume there will be a quick option every time you need one.
  • Museum entrance fees are not included.

One more realistic note: this experience requires good weather, and if it gets canceled due to poor weather, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund. Iceland conditions can change quickly, so it’s smart to keep your schedule flexible.

Value at $865: When a Private Guide Pays Off

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - Value at $865: When a Private Guide Pays Off
At $865, you’re not paying for a cheap seat. You’re paying for planning power and a private experience where your interests steer the day.

So when does it feel like good value?

  • When you have a group where everyone wants something different. Custom routing can prevent one person from dragging the day toward their agenda.
  • When you already did the big bus highlights and you want something smarter and more personal.
  • When you want a guide who can reduce wasted time—your day fills daylight hours because the plan is tailored.
  • When safety and comfort matter, especially for solo travelers. One solo guest specifically said they felt safe and treated like a trusted family member.

Where it may not feel like a bargain:

  • If you’re traveling solo and you just want to ride in a car without much back-and-forth, you might find a cheaper group option that gets you to the classic sites.
  • If you want meals included or restroom access built into the vehicle, this setup doesn’t match that expectation.

The best way to judge value is to ask yourself this: do you want Iceland customized around you, or do you mainly want transportation to famous stops? If you want the first, this price can make sense quickly.

Who This Tour Fits Best (and Who Might Want Something Else)

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - Who This Tour Fits Best (and Who Might Want Something Else)
This is ideal for:

  • Couples or groups who want a private guide and a day built around preferences
  • Travelers who care about more than just photos—history, culture, and interest-led stops
  • Anyone who wants the day to be adjusted based on kids, comfort needs, or specific passions like thermal baths, art, knitting, or saga culture
  • Solo travelers who want a safer-feeling, more personal host rather than a tour machine

It may not be the best match if:

  • You want a fully fixed itinerary with zero decisions
  • You want a built-in meal plan and restroom setup
  • You’re okay with a bus-style day where the guide can’t tailor much in real time

Should You Book Puffin Travel Choice?

Puffin Travel choice - We decide where to go. Do it like locals - Should You Book Puffin Travel Choice?
I’d book this if you want an Iceland day that feels like it has a brain behind it. The big reasons are the personal customization, the guides by name (Gulla and Villi), and the fact that your day can include classic favorites like the Golden Circle and south coast while also reaching more unique areas if you ask.

If you’re already set on the absolute most famous stops and you don’t care about interest-based detours, you can probably find cheaper transport. But if your goal is doing Iceland like locals—where your interests shape the drive—this is a strong choice.

One practical move before you book: message your must-dos in plain language. If you want deeper explanations, say that too. Private tours work best when you and your guide agree on the level of storytelling and the pace you want.

FAQ

How long is the private tour from Reykjavik?

The tour is listed as about 8 to 9 hours, with options that can run roughly 7 to 12 hours depending on what you choose.

What does the price include?

It includes air-conditioned vehicle transportation, Wi-Fi on board, and private transportation. Admission fees to museums are not included.

Is there pickup available?

Pickup is offered.

Is there Wi-Fi during the tour?

Yes. Wi-Fi is included on board.

Are meals included?

No. Meals are not included.

Is there a restroom on the vehicle?

No. There is no restroom on board.

Can I customize the itinerary?

Yes. The guides will shape the day around your interests, including nature, culture/sagas, art, knitting, thermal baths, and activities for children.

What time does the tour start?

The start time is 9:30 am.

What if the weather is bad?

This experience requires good weather. If it’s canceled due to poor weather, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund.